Quantcast
 

Sunday Confessional: I Lied to Keep my Boyfriend from Breaking up with Me

Sun, 04/15/2007 - 9:00am by DearSugar
20,599 Views - 58 comments

My boyfriend and I have been together for just under two years, but the last eight months or so have been extremely rocky. We first got together after he broke off an engagement to a woman he fell out of love with. He told me he wasn't ready to be in a relationship, but things progressed between us and we fell in love.

Everything had been wonderful, and then all of a sudden he became distant. It was almost like he flipped a switch and I could feel him starting to pull away. Last week he told me this relationship was moving too quickly for him and he wanted to take a break. Well, we all know what breaks lead to, so I did something terrible and almost unforgivable-- I lied and told him I was pregnant to make him stay. I know what I did was wrong, dishonest, and cheap, but seeing the look of excitement on his face made it seem not all that bad.

Not only have I trapped myself in a terrible lie, but I also now need to get pregnant!! I feel like I am living in a bad soap opera, but unfortunately it's the mess of a life I made for myself. Will my deception be worth it in the long run or will I be plagued with guilt my entire life?

Source


Read Related:  
on Yahoo!

Related Dear Stories

Related Network Stories


 
 
 

58 Comments Add a Comment

  • Masqueraded_Angel's picture
    Masqueraded_Angel
    1

    Definitely unforgiveable. Why would you do something like that? What do you think he's gonna say when your next period comes along? Do you honestly think that he won't find out? He probably aleady told his family, too. After a couple of months go by and you're not showing signs of being pregnant, it's going to become painfully obvious that you trapped him. The relationship is already going downhill...why would you bring a child into it? You are obviously not mature enough to handle a serious relationship of your own, much less become a mother. I say break the news to him now, but don't expect him to want to become "friends" after this.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • angelbaby2's picture
    angelbaby2
    2

    i agree with masquereaded angel-you need to tell him right away. Do NOT TRY to have a baby-a baby will NOT make him stay in the long run.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • karmapunch's picture
    karmapunch
    3

    I promise you, babies NEVER help rocky relationships.. and you do NOT want to raise a child in an unstable environment- that's just wrong & unfair to that innocent life. If anything, (and I don't recommend this, but if you must) tell him that you misread the results and aren't really pregnant. If he feels the need to take a break, let him go. As corny as that line is, if you love him, let him go. If it was meant to be he'll come back to you.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • tweetie1's picture
    tweetie1
    5

    Tell him the truth now. Do not get pregnant just to cover up your lie. You shouldn't have a child to hold onto a relationship - that is a terrible burden to place on a baby. Lying is not the way to hold onto a relationship. Also the man obviously has commitment issues – a broken engagement and now he is saying things with you are moving to fast?

    You obviously both need to grow up before you have children.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • Thehills101's picture
    Thehills101
    6

    "Now I need to get pregnant" as a mother this to hear this almost makes me sick...do you honsetly think that bringing a child into this will fix things? Maybe it is temporarily pausing the inevitable but in the long run if he isn't ready he will leave, you are a fool to think that he will stay maybe when ur 6 months he'll turn around and be like whoa this is way too much I'm out of here...if you don't want to tell him the truth then atleast tell him you mis carried and let him leave. You cannot trap someone into staying in the long run the only one you would be harming would be yourself, being stuck with a child you are not ready for...and if you went through with the pregnancy do you think it is fair for the child to be brouht into the world not out of love but out of spite to keep someone from leaving??? Honestly I am not a mean person and I don't mean for this to come out so harshly but this isn't healthy for you or him. It's very selfish and it needs to end!!! Put a stop to it before it goes to far!!!
    **Jenn**

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • geenbean's picture
    geenbean
    7

    To forgive or not really isn't the issue here. I agree with everyone else...she needs to grow up, tell her bf the truth and move on from the relationship. It makes me sick to hear "Now I need to go get pregnant!!" It isn't like going to get a haircut or changing your wardrobe.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • fluffyhelen's picture
    fluffyhelen
    8

    If you do manage to get pregnant without him noticing that you first AREN'T then what are you going to do then?

    The look of excitement might have been nice to see but you are clearly not the person he wants to be in a relationship with right now. He would only stay with you (albeit, for how long?) while you were pregnant and then the chances are he'll hightail out of there as soon as the kid has grown up a little!

    It makes me sick when I hear about band-aid babies, it's not worth it.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • nannyblogger's picture
    nannyblogger
    9

    Getting pregnant now would be a moot point...he's still going to realize that something was shady if you have a baby in eleven months instead of nine. Hopefully he'd be smart enough to realize the timeline wasn't quite right. You need to let him figure things out, and you need to accept that if he finds out about this, his choice may be to leave.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • vanyvrgs's picture
    vanyvrgs
    10

    Not forgivable at all. Are you kidding me? You think he cannot count till 9 months? You think keeping a man for a baby let alone a fake baby works? Sorry to say this but beyond pathetic....

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • cubadog's picture
    cubadog
    11

    Completely unforgiveable not question. You need to tell him right now that you are not pregnant. You clearly are not mature enough to handle a relationship let alone responsible enough to raise a child. Now you need to get pregnant is equally I hate to say it stupid. Step up and do the mature, responsible thing and tell him!

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • nicachica's picture
    nicachica
    12

    jeez, is this an episode of "All My Children"???? I swear i saw this storyline a few years ago. these things never end well. you didn't just dig yourself into a hole...more like a crater.

    fess up and tell the truth and then get yourself into counseling. that's just a really horrible thing to do and you need to do some serious self-examination.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • muchacha's picture
    muchacha
    13

    girl, you need to take a step BACK and listen to practically every comment listed above this one..

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • StefaPie's picture
    StefaPie
    14

    Aside from the guy's feelings, you would create a child out of a lie? That's horrifying.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • kh61582's picture
    kh61582
    15

    I put undecided simply because it makes a difference how you proceed from here. If you tell him right away and have a nice long talk about what it was that made you think that this could put your relationship back together then if he's really an understanding type of guy you might have a chance at forgiveness. If you keep this up then it's just plain wrong! If he felt the need to slow things down you should have respected that instead of lying this way. A baby doesn't fix anything. If anything it only causes more problems. Say that you keep this up and get pregnant and you two stay together for a few years, the problems that put you here in the first place will just return. Tell him the truth now and there might be a small chance you could work things out but the chance is probably pretty small but he has a right to know the truth.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • nessabum's picture
    nessabum
    16

    do you really want to bring a baby into this? that's really unfair for your child if you do have one. own up. i don't really care about you or your boyfriend or your relationship--what i DO care about is THE BABY. please be responsible.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • dewzi's picture
    dewzi
    17

    even kids don't keep the relationship together forever these days :\

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • katie225's picture
    katie225
    18

    wow, this is ridiculously messed up. i hope this is a joke! i kinda laughed when she said, "now i need to get pregnant" because that's really not the direction she should take with this lie. the direction to go would be to make up a new lie and tell him you miscarried. omg.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • candy apple's picture
    candy apple
    19

    ok.. i could relate to some of this as i kind of understand where you're coming from. it's hard to face up to a crumbling relationship, and even harder to see the person you love turn their back on you. it could be that he's just scared of seeing his engagement repeat itself. if that's the case you need to give him space, not crowd him with something like this, even if it WERE true.

    now for the lying thing- i have lied to my boyfriend before. not for the same reasons and probably not on the same scale but it was a lie nonetheless and also a pretty serious one. he was kind and understanding enough to hear me out and forgive me. that was of course the best possible outcome but i was prepared for the worst... and i still told him the truth, even though i honestly thought there was 90% chance he would leave me. and that's not because i'm a particularly good person with high ethical standards. and it wasnt because i felt all that guilty. my reason for telling him the truth and putting at risk the one thing that made me happy was that i couldn't stand hurting the one person that matters the most in my life.

    If you are really in love you will understand what i mean- every time he says something nice, every time he tells you how much he cares about you- you will feel guilty for lying. and every minute that passes without him knowing the truth makes the lie bigger, you- a traitor, and him- all the more hurt.

    I would recommend you talk to him right away, start with saying how horrible you feel about it, how much you love him, and how desperate you were to keep him for precisely that reason. After all, isn't that the truth? If he cares for you enough to deal with this and forgive you, he will stick with you in the long run. If he can't forgive, that doesn't make him a bad person, and neither does it mean that your lie was an unforgiveable sin. The fact that you will speak out and tell him the truth is brave enough to atone for that. And if he does leave, it will simply mean that you weren't meant for each other and that you must move on.

    Bottom line is- you can't build or maintain a healthy relationship on a lie. Sooner or later the truth will come out and sooner is always better than later.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • popgoestheworld's picture
    popgoestheworld
    20

    Manipulative much?

    I don't blame the guy for not wanting to be in a relationship with someone who is totally desperate and psycho. What the hell is wrong with you?

    And seriously, is your boyfriend too stupid to do basic math? WTF are you going to say when you go to a doctor's visit together and the doctor calls out your BS lie?

    Don't you dare lie and say you miscarried either. That is just making it worse. You need to own up, and let that guy go find someone who isn't such a selfish person. And you should go get help because people that do this kind of thing are sick.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • t0xxic's picture
    t0xxic
    21

    dont tell him u miscarried and sure as heck dont try and get pregnant. tell him it was a false postive u went the dr and ur not really pregnant and let him choose whether he wants to stay or go. this is not forgiveable if he wants to leave let him he isnt worth it and its not fair to involve a child. men dont know much about pregnancy when it comes to the first child. u can get away with sayin that saying you miscarried is only going to make it worse in the long run bc he could feel compelled to try again and then when you do get pregnant home boys just gonna bail. claim a false positive faulty test hormonal imbalance sorry to get your hopes up and leave it alone.

    im only giving the advice i think might help this situation go away and Im really thinking you need to call it off with this guy u dont get with someone for 2 years and then say ur moving to fast and you def dont lie to keep a man he isnt worth it and you need to re think some things to.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • lickety split's picture
    lickety split
    22

    i think the hole you have dug is going to bury you and this relationship. unfortunately at this point there isn't anything you can do other than wait for everything to collapse. in the next relationship try to remember what you learned here so that this wasn't a total loss. good luck to you.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • SU3's picture
    SU3
    23

    Seriously?? You need to tell him the truth because you WILL be plagued with guilt your entire life. Not only is it wrong, dishonest, or cheap... it's just plain SELFISH. You lied. Now be an adult and fess up to it.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • Marci's picture
    Marci
    24

    Unforgivable. I don't know *what* you were thinking, nor do I know what you continue to think when you say you now need to get pregnant. That's just insanity.

    Your relationship was already shaky and I can sort of imagine why, if you're so quick to make up some an enormous lie to get your boyfriend to stay with you. How completely sad.

    I agree with everyone: Do NOT get yourself pregnant just to cover yourself, and tell him the truth fast. He deserves to hear that, and you should be ashamed of yourself.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • lorenashley's picture
    lorenashley
    25

    OMG..This is flat out terrible. Unforgivable. So very selfish. How could you lie to him like that?? If things weren't working out then that's that. People DO break up that have babies you know. Be honest with the guy, PLEASE. You NEED to get pregnant!!?!? Give me a break. There is so much I want to say but I will stop tying NOW.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • andaman's picture
    andaman
    26

    You did a terrible thing! Sort your head out girl. When he finds out he will get very upset (and so he shoud!) I think you should come clean and pack your things. Give him the break up he wants. You need to sort yourself out before you can start dating again.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • retail_therapy's picture
    retail_therapy
    27

    from what you say about him, he is not even worth you going through this lying thing. if i were you, i would end the relationship

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • cubadog's picture
    cubadog
    28

    What I don't understand are those of you that think covering up a lie with another lie is acceptable. It is not. I had a miscarriage or it was a false positive is a cop out grow-up and do what you know you need to do. Tell him the truth!

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • pinknfluffy's picture
    pinknfluffy
    29

    Okay, I'm not gonna say anything about the pregnancy thing, because I think others have covered that! I can understand you might have said it in a moment of panicked desperation, and I can forgive if you make it right from here on.

    I just wanna say that sometimes you think you love someone enough for the both of you, that your love is great enough to keep you together no matter how he feels. I know what that's like, and I know how it feels to be unable to imagine a future without him.

    Thing is, sooner or later your love is going to turn to resentment. He's gonna feel trapped and retreat into himself, you're going to feel shut out and insecure (which it seems is already happening) and you're going to end up hating each other. The thing about a relationship is that it's only partly about the lovey-dovey romantic feelings. Mostly, it's a partnership, and it takes commitment and work from both sides for it to be good.

    You gotta let this guy go. No matter what his reasons - maybe he's scared of finding himself in the same position as before; maybe he can feel you pushing for more and he's not ready to commit to anyone - these are his issues, and unrelated to you or your relationship. He has to figure himself out before he can be anyone's partner.

    So you guys need to take a step back to figure yourselves out and mature on your own, and maybe you'll realise you're right for each other and build a healthy relationship in which you are both secure and equally loved, or maybe you'll figure you're not right for each other and move on and find the right partner. Either way, trying to cling to this relationship in any way is unfair to him and unfair to you, because you also deserve to be fully loved and cherished.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • boxem180's picture
    boxem180
    30

    my apologies because this is going to be harsh but what the *HELL* where you thinking? this is one of the most unforgivable things a woman could do to someone she is supposed to love. this isn't love, this is control and a fear of being alone. this relationship is over with and a baby will not make this better. a child cannot solve an unhealthy relationship and i'm afraid i can't sympathize with you in this situation.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • LEX0's picture
    LEX0
    31

    THATS A MESS. Y0U'RE JUST LIKE TH0SE 0THER GIRLS, WH0 THINKS HAVING A BABY WILL MAKE A GUY STAY! IVE SEEN IT S0 MANY TIMES THEY'VE G0TTEN PREGNANT & THE GUY STILL DIDNT FALL F0R IT, THEY HAD THE BABY & THERE IS N0 R0MATIC RELATI0NSHIP... N0W THEY'RE JUST A BABY'S M0THER. & THE BABY'S M0THER IS MAD BECUZ HE'S M0VED 0N WITH AN0THER GIRL. IN WHICH Y0U'LL BE IN THE SAME B0AT & N0W Y0U'RE STUCK WITH A BABY ALL BECUZ Y0U WANTED 2 KEEP HIM & HE'S G0NE! N0T SAYING HAVING A BABY IS A BAD THING, BUT ITS BAD WHEN Y0U HAVE 0NE JUST 2 KEEP A GUY... Y0U'RE S0 WR0NG...

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • Deba's picture
    Deba
    32

    I think all the other girls make it pretty clear how childish you are, so I don't wanna go there, my suggestion would be that you say something like you had a delay and you thought you were pregnant or that you misread the test and then let go this guys. When its over its over and there is nothing you can do.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • thatsvy's picture
    thatsvy
    34

    I am a young mother and thank God, we wanted to have this baby together... believe me, you do not want to be stuck raising a baby on your own. It is unfair to everyone involved, maybe even you when you realize you don't love him. This is so childish, it makes me sick. If you don't make it right, right now, you will end up regretting it ten times over... and this isn't a threat, it's a promise!

    x thatsvy

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • vmruby's picture
    vmruby
    35

    Unforgivable ......relationships break up all the time and if he doesn't want to be with you let him go.Children are not a cure-all, they do not fix broken relationships, and IMO should never have any parent/person dump that kind of burden on them to start with.Better fess up soon before it bites you in the a$$ alot worse than it is now.The longer you perpetuate the lie the harder it's going to be to keep it going. Tell him the truth and move on.He may not be the one for you but there is someone out there who is.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • honeysugar28's picture
    honeysugar28
    36

    A fake pregnancy wow! I think you've sunk pretty low to get this guy to stick around temporarily because having a child does not keep two people toguether you can ask any of the million of single mothers out there. But not only that you'll never know how this guy really feels about you do you really want someone to be with you because of commitment that he thinks you're having his baby and not because he loves you? Your relationship is based on lies and deception there's no way this can last for a long time. Think about your actions and start behaving like mature adult.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • rubialala's picture
    rubialala
    37

    Not forgive.

    I try not to judge cuz I have done some REALLY dumb stuff, but that was just a really stupid thing to do. DO NOT get pregnant, it will not solve anything AND you will be bringing an actual human being into the world, not something to take lightly.

    Tell him the truth and be prepared to get dumped.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • PrissyLilBadAss's picture
    PrissyLilBadAss
    38

    Totally unforgiveable! The foundation of your entire relationship is now a total and complete lie. Get out now!

    "Party like a rock star, pound like a porn star, play like an all star!"

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • designergirl's picture
    designergirl
    39

    This is the worst confession by far on this site! I really hope this isn't real becuase I don't understand how anyone could lie like that and then seriously try to get pregnant to cover it up. So selfish.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • Fancy04's picture
    Fancy04
    40

    You should never lie to your mate. Be honest about everything.

    1 year 16 weeks ago Report Comment
  • honey31's picture
    honey31
    41

    Big mistake!If he does not want to be with you than you need to except it!LYing to him about being pregnant is so wrong!

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • SweetFlower's picture
    SweetFlower
    42

    Oh for the love of God, please whatever you do, DON